Hello again! It has been a little bit since I’ve had a chance to work on my 3D printer. @Bjoern you were correct. I found a break in internal copper line beneath the shielding where the bracket meets the wires. It seemed like it got pinched there so bad that when the wires were at the correct angle, it would work, and when the wires were even a little bit off or misaligned, they would not work as well resulting in the error message.
(Strange thing is that I still had normal resistance even when I turned it and moved it, but after cutting away the shielding and taking a closer look. The wires on the inside were definitely broken.)
Just wanted to say thank you all for the help and feedback. It really did save me a lot of time and frustration figuring it all out. 
This is a new area for me, and so far I am back printing again at record speed!
